If you've been watching the news recently, you'll know of the huge debate in the U.S over the role of the Confederate flag in contemporary America. Many see it as a reminder of the many pre-Civil War injustices while others see it simply as a way to honor the soldiers who died for the Confederacy. Many large US companies, like Walmart and Amazon, have already banned the sale of any Confederate flag merchandise as a reaction to the recent events. Now, it appears that Apple has decided to join them by pulling many Civil War wargames from the App Store. As of the writing of this story, games like Ultimate General: Gettysburg and all the Hunted Cow Civil War games are nowhere to be found. Apple is famous for reaching for the axe rather than the scalpel when it comes to political issues (like rejecting Hunted Cow's Tank Battle 1942 for depicting Germans and Russians as enemies), so this move doesn't come as a great surprise.

Apple's Tim Cook has recently spoke against displaying the Confederate flag, so I suppose this development was to be expected. However, censoring historical games (if that is indeed the reason why the games have been pulled) is always very tricky because those games don't glorify or promote a cause but, rather, represent historical events using the symbols and insignia of the period. However, I can also see the political and social pressure mounting at the moment, which makes pulling the games the "safest" action for Apple. What do you think? If Apple has indeed pulled the games for displaying the Confederate flag, is Apple's action justified, or was there another way to eradicate racism and remove the symbols and words that feed it, as Tim Cook put it?
Update: It's looking like Apple has pulled everything from the App Store that features a Confederate flag, regardless of context. The reasoning Apple is sending developers is "...because it includes images of the confederate flag used in offensive and mean-spirited ways." We just spoke with Andrew from HexWar Games, who have released many historical strategy games. He insists, "We're in no way sympathetic to the use of the flag in an offensive way, we used it purely because historically that was the flag that was used at the time."

HexWar Games plans on attempting to re-submit their games using the lesser-known 1861 version of the Confederate flag. But, who knows if that will even be approved. No one is sure yet if Apple is banning all mention of the Confederacy, or just the specific image of the flag which has since become such a hot button issue in the USA.
Update 2: We just received a statement from Maxim Zasov of Game Labs, the developers of Ultimate General: Gettysburg. It is as follows:
We accept Apple's decision and understand that this is a sensitive issue for the American Nation. We wanted our game to be the most accurate, historical, playable reference of the Battle of Gettysburg. All historical commanders, unit composition and weaponry, key geographical locations to the smallest streams or farms are recreated in our game's battlefield.
We receive a lot of letters of gratitude from American teachers who use our game in history curriculum to let kids experience one of the most important battles in American history from the Commander's perspective.
Spielberg’s "Schindler's List" did not try to amend his movie to look more comfortable. The historical "Gettysburg" movie (1993) is still on iTunes. We believe that all historical art forms: books, movies, or games such as ours, help to learn and understand history, depicting events as they were. True stories are more important to us than money.
Therefore we are not going to amend the game's content and Ultimate General: Gettysburg will no longer be available on AppStore. We really hope that Apple’s decision will achieve the desired results. We can’t change history, but we can change the future.
Ultimate General: Gettysburg wasn't alone in focusing on tasteful, historical accuracy. The vast majority of the Civil War strategy games I've played on my iPad put great emphasis on focusing on the historical significance of the battles, units, locations, and generals included. We've also heard that these types of games have been used as teaching tools, making their removal from the App Store feel that much more reactionary.
Update 3: We now have an official Apple statement regarding the removal of the games. Specifically, Apple states that "we have removed apps from the App Store that use the Confederate flag in offensive or mean-spirited ways, which is in violation of our guidelines." Sources close to the company say that it's working with the developers affected by the flag ban to get the issue resolved and get the games back on the App Store. However, the developers will have to either remove or replace the Confederate flag. If this is indeed what Apple is demanding from the developers, it raises all kind of questions about censorship and historical memory as it literally risks rewriting history. Objectionable as it is, the existence of the Confederate flag in these Civil War games is historically accurate, and I'm not sure that any company should have the ability to mold history to its standards and beliefs.
Update 4: Apple has been clarifying their Confederate flag policy with developers who have had their games removed and is working with them to reinstate the games.

-
$3.99
Watch Button Watch App
-
gabed-em
-
gaymerX
-
hincy89
-
AntoxaGray
-
LaDiablaBlanca
-
http://ghita.org/ Serban Ghita
-
http://www.facebook.com/desireelsmith Desiree Smith
-
MrVariant
-
Frank Castle
-
billpayor
-
Chris Culverhouse
-
Mickey Logan
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Wayne
-
Nameless
-
Emerson
-
Mickey Logan
-
Jau
-
Alexa Smith
-
Frank Castle
-
Oly
-
Pat
-
ronald54321
-
Wayne
-
billpayor
-
Jenkem Jones
-
Pavel Drotár
-
Oly
-
Grimloxz
-
Bayz
-
Robin Michael Breeden
-
zombiekiller117
-
Bayz
-
zombiekiller117
-
Bayz
-
zombiekiller117
-
Bayz
-
Егор Бочаров
-
spartusrings
-
Bayz
-
spartusrings
-
Diogenes the Dog
-
Bayz
-
zombiekiller117
-
Jenkem Jones
-
Jenkem Jones
-
Spencer Mack
-
candbar213
-
klepp0906
-
AntoxaGray
-
J. Williams
-
zombiekiller117
-
Emotive
-
AbsolutGrndZer0
-
BrunoFehr
-
AntoxaGray
-
Nameless
-
BrunoFehr
-
Nameless
-
BrunoFehr
-
BrunoFehr
-
Ertik
-
AntoxaGray
-
BrunoFehr
-
BrunoFehr
-
Ertik
-
zombiekiller117
-
Bobby leon
-
AC
-
Minnalousha
-
http://adamsimmersive.com Adams Immersive
-
The Deuce
-
Al B
-
lfdev
-
Diogenes the Dog
-
Nameless
-
http://www.facebook.com/desireelsmith Desiree Smith
-
Mihos Bubastis
-
boxtor
-
BrunoFehr
-
lfdev
-
jr565
-
kiljoy616
-
Space Chief
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
http://politicsy.blogspot.com/ zeph1
-
SMH
-
Al B
-
Chronos Z. Wonderpig
-
Jono
-
Al B
-
Jason Collins
-
Jono
-
Al B
-
AntoxaGray
-
adplatt126
-
SMH
-
Jason Collins
-
Al B
-
Nameless
-
LifePilgrim
-
Al B
-
Nameless
-
CaliforniaLDS
-
Nameless
-
Robert Ivey
-
adplatt126
-
Frank Castle
-
Roberto
-
Nameless
-
Nameless
-
Roberto
-
Nameless
-
http://politicsy.blogspot.com/ zeph1
-
Jenkem Jones
-
John Doe
-
MonsterBansheeRage3D
-
Jim Shorts
-
John Doe
-
Jono
-
Brian Hall
-
Nameless
-
CaliforniaLDS
-
AntoxaGray
-
kiljoy616
-
Mr Smart
-
John Doe
-
NorCal Native
-
Jim Shorts
-
Jono
-
QuarterSwede
-
twitchy67
-
“justpassingthru”
-
Death Lord777
-
Jono
-
CallahanAuto
-
AJ Price
-
CallahanAuto
-
Nameless
-
Spaulding666
-
eddie willers
-
boxtor
-
adplatt126
-
Frank Castle
-
Nameless
-
Asurea
-
Nameless
-
PoodleSheep
-
TheyCallMeBruce
-
The Deuce
-
Keirnoth
-
AAPL.To.Break.$130.Soon>:-)
-
BrunoFehr
-
-
Chris Jones
-
Senza
-
5Cats
-
accolade
-
5Cats
-
accolade
-
hincy89
-
Chris
-
kiljoy616
-
http://ambaryerno.wordpress.com ambaryerno
-
knightmese
-
Dyler_Turden
-
http://illyaking.com/ Illya King
-
mycoolroy
-
Winston_from_the_Ministry
-
Chris Jones
-
vvtim
-
Douche McBags
-
Amanda
-
Nameless
-
Cyclops
-
eddie willers
-
Brian Hall
-
Nameless
-
Sunspot
-
Recon5
-
Jim Shorts
-
ibnt
-
kiljoy616
-
jr565
-
Henric
-
Douche McBags
-
Saatiya Patel
-
yodawgboy
-
Great White
-
Chadwick
-
John Doe
-
Winston_from_the_Ministry
-
Jim Shorts
-
Earl C. Bedford Jr.
-
Jim Shorts
-
Winston_from_the_Ministry
-
Jim Shorts
-
http://donatstudios.com Jesse Donat
-
Milotorou
-
PHUCKO
-
gabed-em
-
Chris Jones
-
bhayes444
-
Velcroe
-
Bouldergore
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
bhayes444
-
jr565
-
Jim Shorts
-
bhayes444
-
visualplayer
-
Joe Marco
-
misterfilmgeek
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
misterfilmgeek
-
Robert Ivey
-
jr565
-
bhayes444
-
Saatiya Patel
-
bhayes444
-
bhayes444
-
yodawgboy
-
J H
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
Masoner
-
jr565
-
Larry Garfield
-
5Cats
-
bhayes444
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
jr565
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
Xifus
-
GoldenOreo
-
model1911
-
Chris Jones
-
5Cats
-
L.j. Lee
-
CJinPA
-
Jonathan Wilson
-
Space Chief
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
TheyCallMeBruce
-
newguy40
-
Robert Ivey
-
YaThunk
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
DotComCTO
-
GoldenHomer
-
Larry Garfield
-
Vincent S.
-
Mike
-
Bob
-
Zero Ehxe
-
iosuser
-
Rick Derris
-
Recon5
-
Eric_D_Read
-
Cardguy63
-
Joe Marco
-
jr565
-
kiljoy616
-
http://jgomo3.blogspot.com/ Jesús Gómez
-
Douche McBags
-
Space Chief
-
OnePissedOffAmerican
-
William Heffron
-
TheyCallMeBruce
-
John Doe
-
gabed-em
-
LifePilgrim
-
Scott Broscious
-
Phil W
-
-
Zero Ehxe
-
rilian
-
Zero Ehxe
-
Robert Ivey
-
rilian
-
visualplayer
-
Jim Shorts
-
Cardguy63
-
Jim Shorts
-
Zero Ehxe
-
Jim Shorts
-
Zero Ehxe
-
Robert Ivey
-
-
Jordan
-
Kahdmus
-
boxtor
-
spartusrings
-
-
LarryECollins
-
Zero Ehxe
-
-
H Rabie
-
Al B
-
smeezekitty
-
Al B
-
Xifus
-
Al B
-
Bouldergore
-
smeezekitty
-
-
https://twitter.com/BrettLoland Brett Loland
-
doug
-
Groot ✓ᵛᵉʳᶦᶠᶦᵉᵈ
-
Brandon Bachman
-
Sunrise250
-
Adrian Ciprian
-
http://www.facebook.com/desireelsmith Desiree Smith
-
AAPL.To.Break.$130.Soon>:-)
-
kogk1943
-
-
Marius S. Moe
-
Jacob Crim
-
klepp0906
-
http://helenspin.com Helen Spingola
-
-
Dailon Huskey
-
naberhaus
-
Brendan Charles
-
-
Cerxop65
-
GoldenOreo
-
StealthDawg
-
zergslayer69
-
Finrod Felagund
-
rare pepe
-
-
Andrew X
-
Kahdmus
-
-
http://wn7ant.com Everett Vinzant
-
Cerxop65
-
James Westfall
-
Cardguy63
-
-
Brendan Charles
-
Jdawg Laurence
-
-
Michael Ritter
-
Dailon Huskey
-
zergslayer69
-
Dailon Huskey
-
Josmur
-
Robert Ivey
-
-
zergslayer69
-
deviladv
-
Robert Ivey
-
-
Zepfhyr
-
FeRoWe
-
Cardguy63
-
-
Robert Ivey
-
-
sivad
-
Dailon Huskey
-
Brendan Charles
-
Dailon Huskey
-
Brendan Charles
-
Dailon Huskey
-
-
-
spsummer
-
Jdawg Laurence
-
-
L0ck
-
chief78
-
zergslayer69
-
deviladv
-
ShinHadoukin
-
deviladv
-
ShinHadoukin
-
ShinHadoukin
-
Walrakin
-
http://wn7ant.com Everett Vinzant
-
ShinHadoukin
-
-
deviladv
-
V the K
-
-
-
icepulse
-
PoloBaquerizoH
-
deviladv
-
Finrod Felagund
-
-
CyberData4
-
Brendan Charles
-
-
V the K
-
GoldenOreo
-
ShinHadoukin
-
GoldenOreo
-
http://wn7ant.com Everett Vinzant
-
GoldenOreo
-
GoldenOreo
-
Jay G
-
Xifus
-
Finrod Felagund
-
GoldenOreo
-
Finrod Felagund
-
GoldenOreo
-
http://wn7ant.com Everett Vinzant
-
GoldenOreo
-
Xifus
-
-
-
a_apple
-
Finrod Felagund
-
sivad
-
-
Zepfhyr
-
thematrixx
-
GoldenOreo
-
Finrod Felagund
-
GoldenOreo
-
-
-
Jim Shorts
-
http://wn7ant.com Everett Vinzant
-
Jim Shorts
-
-
rwrife
-
cofunguy
-
Milotorou
-
-
Trevor
-
StealthDawg
-
raresloth
-
GoldenOreo
-
Finrod Felagund
-
Sparafucile
-
GoldenOreo
-
Finrod Felagund
-
rare pepe
-
-
-
hincy89
-
hincy89
-
bigE1669
-
lancesackless
-
http://www.6beersin.com/ evil nick
-
nicoper
-
Milotorou
-
Ty Thompson
-
Andrew X
-
rajjmuhammed
-
barefootdragon
-
mycoolroy
-
Andrew X
-
http://ScottSoapbox.com/ Scott Soapbox
-
Senza
-
http://ScottSoapbox.com/ Scott Soapbox
-
-
Jay G
-
-
mycoolroy
-
Dailon Huskey
-
Andrew X
-
-
James
-
Brian Hall
-
B-Sabre
-
-
mycoolroy
-
hippiesrlame
-
red sweater
-
https://pcbushi.wordpress.com/ Bushi
-
Alex_Gol
-
Difster
-
Dewey Defeats Truman
-
Steve Magnus
-
banned
-
Sir_Brizz
-
Retro Nug
-
cusman
-
Hiker0
-
banned
-
Sir_Brizz
-
banned
-
-
mycoolroy
-
-
http://innoveight.ca Trev Page
-
Shari Romine Webster
-
http://innoveight.ca Trev Page
-
Jim Shorts
-
-
-
Tom
-
mycoolroy
-
Shari Romine Webster
-
Megamatics
-
-
gleeclub
-
Bill Lescallette
-
mycoolroy
-
Megamatics
-
satta
-
icepulse
-
HelperMonkey
-
Jim Shorts
-
-
http://adamsimmersive.com Adams Immersive
-
klink
-
Nicky Ian Kunesh
-
-
JoAnn Kennedy
-
The Vole
-
thestapler
-
Quazonk
-
curtisrshideler
-
nonstickron
-
Wonderkarp
-
sivad
-
Wonderkarp
-
-
-
gemiinii
-
Brendan Charles
-
Nonscpo
-
Jeanne Price
-
Robert Stukenbroeker
-
http://theexpressioninstinct.blogspot.com/ Sam
-
Finrod Felagund
-
HelperMonkey
-
Finrod Felagund
-
-
-
MrSonicAdvance
-
Relativicus
-
Earl C. Bedford Jr.
-
-
lorriman
-
jr565
-
rare pepe
-
mycoolroy
-
5Cats
-
-
Tobias Holmes
-
5Cats
-
-
hincy89
-
5Cats
-
-
Stryker412
-
Jake7905
-
-
Bouldergore
-
5Cats
-
mycoolroy
-
-
YaThunk
-
Jake7905
-
-
Nicole
-
mycoolroy
-
-
mike
-
mycoolroy
-
-
Jake7905
-
mycoolroy
-
-
the_rebel14
-
http://illyaking.com/ Illya King
-
-
P Gustaf
-
L.j. Lee
-
Eric Hutchison
-
Brendan Charles
-
-
Haanden
-
Eric Hutchison
-
-
Press2Play
-
Keith Cameron
-
DCRussell
-
Cardguy63
-
Mr_Assault
-
mycoolroy
-
-
-
Jay G
-
HarryWarden
-
mycoolroy
-
-
Mr Smart
-
Andrew X
-
LarryWP
-
-
-
ryan
-
predator8u
-
Eggard Snark
-
David Miller
-
Carolyn Garcia
-
LarryWP
-
MirriamE
-
Piph
-
LarryWP
-
-
mycoolroy
-
holymoly
-
LarryWP
-
-
Carolyn Garcia
-
mycoolroy
-
Joshua Woodward
-
http://www.mynameisjay.com/ Jay
-
http://ambaryerno.wordpress.com ambaryerno
-
NewWorldPress
-
MirriamE
-
-
A Andrews
-
MirriamE
-
Bill
-
CNN_deletes_so_many_Posts
-
http://authorsdb.com/authors-directory/1824-alan-w-jankowski Alan Jankowski
-
Candor Spot
-
J Hunt Morgan
-
LarryWP
-
-
Qaioud
-
Masoner
-
Ethan Sams
-
Alexythimia23
-
August West
-
Deroni76
-
agamemnus
-
Anon
-
Andrew Bolt
-
-
michaelmastro
-
http://randomnerds.com/ Random Nerds
-
Johnny Davis
-
agamemnus
-
-
Stormourner of the Nature
-
Dan Mulhollen
-
Ziegler45314
-
LarryWP
-
-
molly Ring
-
Al B
-
Rothschild_Empire
-
Al B
-
Rothschild_Empire
-
-
-
mycoolroy
-
ima_robot_beepbeepbeep
-
jr565
-
Ryan E. Hoffman
-
Meko21
-
John Doe
-
Nikolai Rogers
-
Lyn Bruner- McKinney
-
Cyclops
-
steve9930
-
https://twitter.com/SmileyRoffle Smiley
-
Sugarlarry
-
Winston_from_the_Ministry
-
-
http://mikebethany.com/ Mike Bethany
-
Kenny Peacock
-
Chronos Z. Wonderpig
-
Jim Shorts
-
EyesAndFKno
-
adz4u28
-
Raki_Saeki
-
CandeeandHerald Botone
-
Furydeath
-
sublbc
-
NorCal Native
-
Brett Loland
-
jattapake
-
NorCal Native
-
-
http://www.jlinnation.com/ JLinNation
-
Frank W. Abernathy
-
boB
-
ChasInNJ
-
http://www.sepulchreofheroes.blogspot.com/ Gothmog
-
Tetra84
-
Tom Cook
-
NorCal Native
-
Hard2find
-
-
Nivrap
-
http://toriko.wikia.com/wiki/Toriko_Encyclopedia CaptainGintoki
-
jin choung
-
General Deshler
-
Ryan Hall
-
muttso1o
-
AS55423
-
-
AS55423
-
tech53
-
mourningair
-
Not My Name
-
http://www.sepulchreofheroes.blogspot.com/ Gothmog
-
Penelope Peace
-
Phil B.
-
Ultimate Warrior
-
Death Lord777
-
Kevin Wall
-
Patrick Phillips
-
TheGodless
-
-
thatswellguyandy
-
mycoolroy
-
-
Jeffrey Lange
-
CaliforniaLDS
-
Richard Held
-
Young Werther
-
Jack Brown
-
Brandon Bachman
-
Jack Brown
-
-
-
Brandon Bachman
-
Mesocyclones
-
Brandon Bachman
-
-
-
Jean-Paul DuQuette
-
Rip73
-
leatherneckga
-
Rip73
-
Aaron Richards
-
Rip73
-
-
-
Cheryl Jefferies
-
Virginia Black
-
Mesocyclones
-
Rip73
-
-
Cyber Slammer
-
Ted Seay
-
Ricotta
-
lfdev
-
Ken Cella
-
alan scout
-
lfdev
-
IMWMWMI
-
7skuareoff
-
Greenfort
-
luckiestmanalive8
-
jmw_123
-
metheoldsarge
-
AntoxaGray
-
Robert Ivey
-
adplatt126
-
Benjamin Rodriguez
-
Michael Kochin
-
Winston_from_the_Ministry
-
Sugarlarry
-
-
xvicex
-
edjcox
-
Brady2600
-
Knott
-
Knott
-
Knott
-
Adrian Werner
-
Shane K
-
http://www.facebook.com/desireelsmith Desiree Smith
-
kogk1943
-
AAPL.To.Break.$130.Soon>:-)
-
Pavel Drotár
-
accolade
-
kogk1943
-
-
hawkdoc60
-
Marius S. Moe
-
-
Marc Williams
-
MVH
-
Oly
-
Enough is Enough
-
quarterStar
-
1517Genevieve
-
Jay Rawls
-
n4zhg
-
quarterStar
-
-
Alois Sečkár
-
https://pcbushi.wordpress.com/ Bushi
-
http://webinfotech.tzo.com/ Chelmsford_Resident
-
Rupert Chappelle
-
klepp0906
-
http://www.StudioBrule.com/ Steve Brulé
-
Gayla Warner
-
jimmyray1972
-
MyAllah
-
fedup
-
TruePatriot
-
Its about time
-
Its about time
-
http://www.adwebdesigns.com Bill Scott
-
FQTTraveler
-
slimgrin
-
Rick6981
-
vhelixv
-
LarryWP
-
-
spartusrings
-
quarterStar
-
spartusrings
-
quarterStar
-
spartusrings
-
-
-
Gail Van der Linden
-
Joe
-
Abigail Davenport
-
vhelixv
-
-
scott white
-
scott white
-
Chris Culverhouse
-
Jdawg Laurence
-
Al Sullivan
-
AbsolutGrndZer0
-
Jamie Clemons
-
rorschach2
-
BrunoFehr
-
David W
-
Adam WP2020
-
Stephen Dupree
-
Jason Petty
-
TheSilverRanger
-
Nameless
-
JH
-
Nameless
-
Turney
-
JuanTizmo
-
farkennel
-
-
Alexa Smith
-
kill the masters
-
mcross
-
farkennel
-
-
GarretKadeDupre
-
Bobby leon
-
-
Heather Smith Pennington
-
Bobby leon
-
-
Bobby leon
-
Pat
-
-
http://www.khaaan.com furious_a
-
Battlestar
-
John Burney Sr
-
quarterStar
-
-
David
-
Kenneth Spell
-
Juan S.
-
Veritas88
-
WronglyRabbit
-
-
Incognito
-
JRSCline
-
farkennel
-
Alexa Smith
-
Indyalpha
-
Xenothon
-
james
-
pygmymouse
-
quarterStar
-
-
ronald54321
-
P G
-
Andy
-
Irvin
-
Telstar
-
W Anderson
-
TheJawster777
-
spartusrings
-
-
Shane McCausland
-
jmitterii2 .
-
Gaius Pilum
-
Dolphin Lover
-
Indyalpha
-
scprguy
-
David Anderson
-
spartusrings
-
Bayz
-
spartusrings
-
Bayz
-
spartusrings
-
Bayz
-
-
-
NoLifeDGenerate
-
Darkslicer
-
-
Minnalousha
-
Robert
-
Bob2563
-
Em Parkessen
-
writergal
-
TruthForToday
-
Dickey
-
Pavan Kumar Sake
-
Randy Bailey



