looks amazing so far, controls look a little hard tho.

i bought the game and it keeps crashing before i can play it. i have asphalt 4 and it constantly crashes as well (both from gameloft). i have an iphone and am not sure if there is a setting somewhere to prevent this. does anyone have any suggestions. i want to play this game i payed 10$ for!!!!

Graphically it looks amazing, and after the 20-30 minutes it seems it would take to get the controls down it looks like it would be a lot of fun.

I'm just a little amazed at how good the graphics are in this game. I mean, this is looking as good as PSOne graphics and for a platform that also features phone and internet functionality it is just amazing.

this game looks awesome (for a shooter on the iPhone that is) must... hold...back...from...getting....it...till....more...reviews....come.......OUT!!!

AHAHAHAHAHA!!!

Damn Apple and their App store. It's like crack!

that looks absolutley amazing - this looks really much more like a FPS, easier to control then cube!

As I do not doubt that future iphones will get hardware updates, I wonder how far gaming on the iphone will be pushed in the future. Why would I buy a PSP, DS or anything else?

It will only get better!

Wow. They should totally charge more for that game, if anything just to help "restore the balance" to the broken pricing model.

c-note,
Reboot your iPhone. It often happens after having installed apps, especially big ones.

mine just leaves a blank screen! help me! im on old ipod touch if thats a factor.

ahhhhhhh......rebooting your phone. just got it about 2 weeks ago and am still figuring it out. it works perfectly now. thanks guys.
this game really doesn't look like it would be on a "phone". i am still surprised how good these games are.

Mine leaves a blank screen too, well, actually it's an empty springboard to be exact, which looks blank for those who haven't jailbroken.

yeah im jailbroken too so does that make it crash?

No, not necessarily, because I've read on another forum of a jailbroken user playing the game just fine.

well im rebooting now so ill see if it works

rebooting doesnt work. ill send a complaint to gameloft.

Won't work for me either... JB 2.2

Wow
with these graphics

some REALLY REALLY GOOD RPG's can come through for the ipodT's and iphones

c'mon SQUARE-ENIX, when is your turn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

I'm JB'ed and it works flawlessly.

I'm JB'ed and it works flawlessly. (2.2 without baseband update)

baseband update?

Those with broken jailbroken iPhone shouldn't send a complaint to Gameloft because in a way they're only meant for non-JB iPhones. It's not their responsibility AT ALL.

Well, it does not work on my iPhone 2G (jailbreak). But it does on my iPod Touch 2G. So its probably a memory issue ...

Has it the same framerate issues than the DS version or does it run smooth? I mean: "REALLY smooth"

this is the exact game I played on the DS

Wow it's exactly the same of the ngage version, same levels same position of enemies.

Looks great. Shame it doesn't look like the trailer, though (not that it ever could!)

Albee, do you think that's a good or bad point thing? (Genuine question)

Attention all Jailbreakers!

The crash on launch (blank screen) can be fixed by removing winterboard!

i found how to fix!!!!!!!@#@#!

try to open the game 5 to 7 time in a row and it will start to work eventually

hahah!!!!!!!!! enjoy

realy work!

Removing Winterboard?

Naturally. The only reason I jailbreak is now the only reason I can't play the only game I'm interested in playing. Figures.

I wonder if the cracked .ipa would work? I mean, I DO own the game ...

Brothers in Arms: Hour of Heroes not work 2.2 but working for 2.1 !
please, fix now !

@mavis:
LOL, that's ironic.

I have a JB ipod too was really pissed when i found out i had to remove winterboard for the majority of my apps to work. Terrible. Luckily, i've managed to inform HHG, and i'm sure now many people will see what a waste of time JB'ing their ipod is now. Sigh.

I have a JB ipod too was really pissed when i found out i had to remove winterboard for the majority of my apps to work. Terrible. Luckily, i've managed to inform HHG, and i'm sure now many people will see what a waste of time JB'ing their ipod is now. Sigh.

I have solved the crash problem. Just turn on 'safe mode' from sbsettings and than run the game. No need to remove any program. Enjoy

fix for 2.1 crashing!!

try to open the game 5 to 7 time in a row and it will start to work eventually

it work!!!

tnx 2 me

Runs fine on my 2.2 (non-JB )

I don't think you can fault Gameloft for the game not running on hacked phones

The controls take some getting used to, I still haven't decided what I like best. Only problem with a game like this is that your thumbs end up covering a lot of the screen, but I guess that's inevitable with the iphone.

The graphics are pretty good (i guess there's a limit to how much we can expect from the iPhone) and the production value is excellent - great soundtrack, voice and sound-FX.

The biggest problem is learning to control your character, I hope it get's better with practice

But looking at what similar games cost for other platforms $9.99 is a steal, even though in iPhone-land it "seems" expensive.

One annoyance: it seems to play the intro video everytime you start the game, with no possibility to skip past it

I'm impressed. Looks better than the DS game could. Resolution + smooth textures. Controls look like a reasonable compromise and seem to work well for this type of game. Sure you can't "circle strafe" but that is such an artificial video game thing anyway.

Now, what needs to happen is MAJOR SUCCESS for this game so that high-quality full-featured games are attracted to the platform. It's great to have the value games, but the potential for an wider variety of games is certainly there on this platform. RPGs especially. Square Enix has to impressed by the storage (un)limitations alone, right? ;o)

++ against complaining to a developer that a game doesn't work on a jailbroken iPhone. (or even thinking about it)

I'm impressed. Looks better than the DS game could. Resolution + smooth textures. Controls look like a reasonable compromise and seem to work well for this type of game. Sure you can't "circle strafe" but that is such an artificial video game thing anyway.

Now, what needs to happen is MAJOR SUCCESS for this game so that high-quality full-featured games are attracted to the platform. It's great to have the value games, but the potential for an wider variety of games is certainly there on this platform. RPGs especially. Square Enix has to impressed by the storage (un)limitations alone, right? ;o)

++ against complaining to a developer that a game doesn't work on a jailbroken iPhone. (or even thinking about it)

Oh man, I said I would be cutting my ipihone game budgets but my god does this game look fun

Hi guys,

read something about the 1g IPT being less capable with games than iPhones and the 2g IPT. Anyone with an original IPT having problems with this game, before I buy it?

"One annoyance: it seems to play the intro video everytime you start the game, with no possibility to skip past it"

Peter321, most game intro videos (include the one for BIA) behave just like regular iPhone videos, which means you can always tap to access control, then hit "Done" to skip them.

I've played through the first two missions so far, and though the d-pad control is a bit dodgy (which I'm sure could be fixed in an update), I am very, very impressed.

The more I play it, the more I like it. Need more strategy and tactical FPS!

Then my life would be complete. Heeeee!

Wow, that's really fun! I'm impressed, because it looked difficult to control at first, but 5 minutes in the first mission and you're a pro!

Its awesome, works great on JB Ipod 1G, it havent crashed at all.
Nice games from Gameloft.

Wow, that is really cool! I need a towel just from watching the gameplay footage. What I can't get over is the audio... lots of chatter... gunfire... things blowing up! Nice!!!!

Just need a car chase and some boobies.

I already finished it!!

It runs really smoothly, no noticeable slowdowns or anything.

The automatic checkpoint system is pretty awesome. If I had a call or otherwise had to quit the app during gameplay I could pretty much continue where I left off.

At first the controls were quite hard to handle, but I got use to them pretty quickly. The jeep handling is still hard IMO.

If they added multiplayer with the next update I'd be willing to pay another 8 euros for it! Or more.

attention all jailbreakers- follow the advice of a few posts above me, enable safe mode from sbsettings!!! it works i literally just fixed my blank screen problem, don't write gameloft

Holy crap, this is a cellphone game??? Amazing stuff!!

But yeah, someone please release a good role-playing game! Port KOTOR and FF VII at least!!

Holy crap, this is a cellphone game??? Amazing stuff!!

But yeah, someone please release a good role-playing game! Port KOTOR and FF VII at least!!

@Peter

Ah i found it already :') I'ts under the 'power' button.

It finaly works now!

How do you enable safe mode from SBSettings?

I don't see safe mode anywhere...

It's not under the Power button.

This is almost identical to the N-gage game that i bought 3 months ago for my old Nokia n95

http://www.ngage.com/ngi/ngage/web/g0/en/showroom/gamedetail.269.GameDetail.html#

Its good but not great and I am a little disappointed as it feels like i bought the same game twice!

If you can't run the game just keep trying. Press the game icon and when you see the blank spingboard press the "escape" button. Repeat as many times as you have to. I do it three times. It's likely a bug that they'll address in a future update and has nothing to do with JBs or not.

As far as the game is concerned the controls are awful. It's a shame but not really gameloft's fault..

Argg its ugly and the controls looks terrible!

I also can't see the safe button anywhere in SBsettings, help me find it please

Itouch if tried 10 times and it didnt work.

iAmSeven: in the bossprefs its not under the power button but if you swipe accros the top bar on your iPhone you get a shortcut menu that slides in from the top. (i think this is standard?) Then you have press the power button and then you get all these options:

cancel
reboot
Power Off
Lock
Safe Mode

press the last one

What also works is setting it in airplane mode!

M1ch3l apparently it is a memory issue for you, that's why its working in safe mode and airplane mode (obviously you are talking about an iphone). Check your background apps that run in the memory and if you can turn some off. Maybe you have a video wallpaper background or something that animates and uses memory (assuming you are JB), or even a heavy application that you installed recently and runs in the backgroung without showing. The iphone's baseband is memory consuming enough on its own.

A lot of people here seem to "knock" GAMELOFT - not quite sure why? I have bought their games on my SONY K800 and they have always been pretty good. I have bought a games from them on IPOD TOUCH and they have also been good quality (guitar rock tour, midnight bowling, RF09). I think this new game looks spot on and just need to justify the 5.99 hit to my credit card!
Re - Jailbroken phones/Ipods, if you are going to hack hardware, that is (unfortunately) the price you pay. Should developers take this into account? In my opinion - no.

Gameloft is actually one of the best in mobile platforms. I have played many of their games in many cell phones and their releases are always top notch. I don't think anybody "knocks' them off.
However, like I said the controls in this game suck although it's not really their fault. The touchscreen cannot allow decent controls for games like this.
Jailbroken devices have no problem running apps (including this one) just like un-jailbroken ones do. Something else is always the problem.

This game rocks!! But um... I'm at a point where it's telling me to throw a smoke grenade and when I do... nothing happens. lol. It's on the Normandy "Cloud Dagger" mission. Anyone else having this problem or have any tips on getting past it?

Mini-Review:

Graphics: 8/10 pretty detailed best for the Iphone/Touch so far (though it's really the only 3rd person shooter..lol), little slowdown, good clean textures easily something on par with 1st generation PSone. I can't wait to see what developers will have on the Iphone/Touch. (Bring on Hero of Sparta). Though I wish the beggining trailer did not show graphics from the PC and Console versions, makes the actual game look anemic by comparison.

Sound: 8/10 very solid, good sound effects very clear voices, awesome with Headphones).

Control: 7/10 I gave this a 7 as it's not as precise as having an analog stick. But, good enough for now. Love that you can choose multiple control types. The game does have Auto Aim/lock enabled.

Gameplay: 8/10 Very solid, great for a handheld that isn't a PSP or DS.
It is standard 3rd person shooter, but as it's the only one of it's kind so far it definitely raises my expectations.

Replay: 3/10 SHort, but for $10 can't expect too much. Ad-hoc Mulitplayer wouldn've been nice.

Overall: 8/10 It's a great game, for my book definitely worth the $10, though my guess is that it'll drop to 7.99 in a week or so..lol
I say support Gameloft, so they can continue to produce more Iphone/Touch games.

This game is just a port of a game ported to the ds from mobile. Although it has a graphical upgrade, it's really the same game. Is it really worth praising gameloft for porting a several year old game to a new platform?

About the Whining Jailbreakers....

I can't tell you how many People slammed my game, TouchSports Tennis - DAILY - on iTunes!!! They delete and re-post their *One Star * review saying the game is unstable and wont work.

Telling me to fix the problem!!!! UUGGH!!!! More importantly telling potential customers my game is unstable....

This has taken a game that should be at 4.5 stars down to 3. I remember when I used to mod my system and if I configured something wrong... it was MY FAULT.

They expect me to figure out their problem. It's great to hear the smart ones out there saying to Stop Blaming Developers for innovation!

Thx!
HHG

HHG, How comes there are TONS of games that bigger than yours work perfectly OK on a JB iPhone? I never put any comment in iTune but just can't resist to respond. Just drop your BS excuse and fix the memory bugs in your game!

@ninjaw

Your remark is only partially valid:

1. In the ideal world, yes, a game should just work on al platforms, as many appear to (complexities of the specific games unspecified),

but

2. If one has a jailbroken phone and the app works on non-jail broken phones/IPT, the app store is NOT the place to lodge the complaint. It should be taken up in a forum/blog, perhaps like this one, where developers and other saavy iphone users can perhaps decipher the problem. Thus, it is the dev's freedom to legitimately express a complaint over this broken app store rating process.

@all the whiny developers

im sorry, but its safe to say about 50% of iphone uses have jailbroken their units. Its not good practice to insult half of your potential market for getting the most out of their phone. get your goddamn software working or shut the hell up and take the criticism. thats all there is to it. A smart developer will test it on both factory set, and jailbroken.

@kam

Problem is, on a non-JB phone the developer knows what limits he has to stay withing - that's the beauty of Apples closed 1-app at a time system (whether you like it or not).

On a JB phone, the users can run all sorts of background tasks that can take up both memory and CPU cycles. This will be independent from user to user, so the developer has no chance of testing whether his app will work in this environment or not - it may work for one JB setup, but not for another that has more or larger background tasks running.

Apple has provided a pretty consistent platform for developers (although the Ipod Touch V2 is faster) and I think that is one of the reason we already have 10.000 apps in an app store that is less than 5 months old.

If you JB - you are on your own, you are using an unsupported configuration.

If I chip my car and the engine breaks down because of it, I can't complain to the dealer and demand a replacement

As SalsaMD says, issues with JB phones should be discussed in forums and blogs, not in the iTunes rating system, it is unfair to the developer and will ultimately be bad for the end-user as well (if the game gets an unfair bad rating, sales will sufffer and the developer makes less money to develop new and better games).

Please consider that if you are going to accept review copies it might be better to have an actual review. Saying a game has good graphics and decent controls isn't a review, that's a casual observation. If developers can only give out 50 copies and then you offer only the most superficial information they'll probably go elsewhere, and the readers will follow (or maybe leave first).

I'm not saying this to be a jerk, it just seems like maybe you don't realize that you have the opportunity of a lead but lack content other than a simple aggregation of games. It won't take long for someone to flesh out a site with better content though.

so, a JB 2.2 (without basebade updatE) iphone 3g would run this game? only jailbroke it to unlock my phone (my simcard is old, it needs jailbreaking to activate) but not using winterboard or anything (don't even have cydia/installer).

@ Ahiru Normally, yes it will.

@ Kam

I'm sorry, but it is safe to say that you are an utter arse if you think 50% of people have Jail broken their phones. It is far more likely to be 0.05% than it is 50%.

if you have a jailbroken iPhone and stuff does not work don't complain to the developers, complain to the person who made the hacked firmware. It's their fault!
It's like buying a Mac and putting Windows on it. Then getting mad at Apple when the system crashes and gets viruses.

I could not wait any more for a review and I downloaded the game. Can't wait to try it out. i'll post my review in a bit.

Are they playing that game using the iphone's regular speakers, or is it connected to an external speaker system? It sounds too loud on video to be from the iphone alone.

no problems with crashing yet.

after i installed the app and restarted my phone it has run fine

no problems with crashing yet.

after i installed the app and restarted my phone it has run fine

someone was saying that they keep crashing..is this after the brother of arms logo comes up, and a black screen pops up? well to adress this problem i open the game up multiple times until a white gameloft screen comes up assuring me its about to play properly.
This game so far has astounded me, im amazed that the iphone can play such briliant games. Id be willing to pay a heap for this game im loving it.!!!
you wont regret this game. even the quotes are good. love it.

i got my response from gameloft and they said that it is a problem that they are aware of and will fix in the next update out next week. So its not just JB'd iphones that have the problems. Doesnt matter tho cuz i got it fixed already.

I've having the same grenade problem to Clark M, on both Cloud Dagger of the Nomandy campaign and the Tutorial missions. The problem appears to be that I can't work out how to throw the thing further than a few feet in front of me. Am I being completely stupid?

Jailbroken 2.2 iPhone 2G

As said before by somebody else, if you try several times to get the game to start it will eventually work.

Nice game for a phone.

In answer to my own question, yes, I am being stupid. Just discovered that tipping the phone forward enables you to aim the grenade further forward.

Can this game be played on any other platforms other than Apple? like Blackberry?

Fix for Brothers In Arms (Jailbroken iPhone 3G) read the article, http://tr.im/1xen

I have contemplated this game since it was released, read a thousand articles and posts, and bought probably 50 other games while trying to decide if I wanted to drop a whopping $10 bucks for it.

Man this is a killer game!

My comparison is probably poor, but I'll put it out there anyway. Before I sold my PSP, I bought Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six:Las Vegas. In my humble opinion BIA kicks the crap out of that game! They are fairly similar, but the graphics on Rainbow seemed choppy comp. to BIA. Character models in BIA look convincingly like Nazi military and the scenery and backdrops feel right. In that Clancy game, movements, actions and surroundings just felt so.. Confined, or blocky not sure the actual word to describe it. I played that Clancy game for maybe a total of 3 hours (I didn't beat it, too blasé). I payed $39.99 for that piece of elephant dung!!

I am happy paying the $10 for BIA, and I can already tell I'll beat the ham and replay it, and get more than 3hrs of enjoyment from it. Not to say I enjoyed the Vegas game, those 3 hrs were spent getting frustrated, not what a game should be like.

Thanks Gameloft, next time you guys release a game that interests me I will not be so apprehensive to push that "buy now" button.

Man that "beat the ham" comment came off weird didn't it? Apple; quit toying with my words while I type on my phone!!!!!!

Corrected word is game. Lol

I just bought it, can't wait to go home, lie on my bed, and play this bad boy!