This is everyone's personal opinion here, but what apps do you think need better icons? I miss Defender Chronicles' old icon lol. That and apps with the black backgrounds that blend in with the ipod (Doom Resurrection, Star Hogs, Zenonia, etc. aren't good for icons IMO)
Cartoon Wars is desperately in need of a new icon, and so is The Wars. Both are great games that are slightly lacking in the art department.
Icons that could use a change: Zenonia, Brothers In Arms, Rolando series, Circuit_Strike One, GeoFighter Light Wars, Siberian Strike, Nano Fighter, Cartoon Wars, Farm Frenzy, Ragdoll Blast, iYamato, Tyrian, and most of all Earth vs Mars Icons that I love: Real Racing, Spider: The Secret Of Bryce Manor, Fieldrunners, Blimp, FAST, Baseball Slugger and the new Galcon icon. Oh, that Ironman icon I saw in the Rate My Apps thread here looks hot as well.
Touchgrind, Quantum Collapse, Defender Chronicles, Knights Onrush and Underworlds. I dont really like any of those.
This topic is bizarre. I thought the question was asking which apps actually had bad icons, but you guys seem to be listing perfectly good icons just cause you're in the mood for a change. It's like changing your desktop wallpaper, you could do it for every app every single week.
I'd like for Circuit_Strike to go back to its old icon... Now looking through my list of apps on my iPod, the ones I'd like to be changed to something better(not as ugly): Sphaira(I think a new one is coming) Ant Wars Kapsel Racer(great game, icon looks a bit cheap) Magnetrox
Wacky World Golf - This icon is Terrible. It looks so thrown together, pure crap. Defender Chronicles - Love the old one, hate the new one. In fact, I can't even look at it. Another crap icon for a great game Pipe Mania - Just awful Worms - I like the itunes icon much better What's the Difference (JVL) - All of their other icons are nice, this one sucks. Radial 50 - Great game, generic icon. Take influence from Breakspin for a new one. Mahjong Artifacts II - I like the original icon much better. Should have been left alone Kapsel Racer - This icon blows. Their icon for ifoosball kicks ass, what the hell happened to Kepsel Racer? Drawrace - I don't like characters on the icon that are simply not in the game. This big doofus makes an appearance on splash screens, that's about it. Get a new icon, PLEASE!!! Monkey Island - Can we have the itunes icon instead, please?
Pipe Mania - Please change the icon. For the love of God. Hydrotilt - I just think it's ugly everything else is good/tolerable
gangstar - so terrible i forget i even have the game! pipemania - agreed there, not the best krazykart - weird choice of icon that, dont like it anyways ifruitbomb - really naff and cheap frootrees - i actually preferred the original icon this game had Eliss - erm .. dull!