Yeah... the only pokemon I gave a crap about enough to level up to 88 after years of playing. And then I one day accidentally overwrote the data, losing my level 88 Feraligatr and years and years of playing...
It's not a pokemon. it's a glitch "pokemon" from the first Red/Blue gameboy days. It's really quite interesting why it comes up though... and how to do it is simple as hell.
Sorry for the flaming earlier! FVMatt, that looks like one great team you have there. I'm putting together my big team right now. Does anyone have a Scyther they would like to trade?