• Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Hot Games
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Product Reviews

    • Defender Chronicles (TD) - which icon?

    Discussion in 'Upcoming iOS Games' started by Gimka, Apr 15, 2009.

    Thread Status:
    Not open for further replies.
    ?

    Which icon is better?

    1. Icon1

      48 vote(s)
      63.2%

    2. Icon2

      19 vote(s)
      25.0%

    3. Neither

      9 vote(s)
      11.8%
    Page 2 of 3
    1. Kris Jones

      Kris Jones Well-Known Member

      Mar 21, 2009
      1,012
      0
      0
      Producer/Publisher/Designer of Mobile Games
      America
      #21 Kris Jones, Apr 16, 2009
      Aren't you violating any copyright and intellectual property laws by having a Hobbit?
       
    2. snow_mani

      snow_mani Well-Known Member

      Oct 20, 2008
      1,186
      18
      0
      Melbourne, Australia
      #22 snow_mani, Apr 16, 2009
      Icon 2

      I voted for icon 2. To me it is brighter, more eyecatching and grabs my interest more than icon 1.
       
    3. Gimka

      Gimka Well-Known Member

      Dec 27, 2008
      340
      0
      0
      #23 Gimka, Apr 16, 2009
      Kris Jones,
      That’s correct. But they are actually called Halfling in the game. Thanks for the concern :)
       
    4. Gimka

      Gimka Well-Known Member

      Dec 27, 2008
      340
      0
      0
      #24 Gimka, Apr 16, 2009
      TouchArcade, this is what you have voted for this game.

      And based on your feedbacks, our graphic artists have improved the icon further.

      [​IMG]

      snow_mani, thanks for the feedback. Hopefully, you like the look of the new icon too.
       
    5. Mr. Charley

      Mr. Charley Well-Known Member

      Sep 6, 2008
      2,629
      38
      38
      #25 Mr. Charley, Apr 16, 2009
      That's a much nicer looking icon! :)
       
    6. snow_mani

      snow_mani Well-Known Member

      Oct 20, 2008
      1,186
      18
      0
      Melbourne, Australia
      #26 snow_mani, Apr 17, 2009
      Nice. The improved icon 1 is much better than the original version! :)

      But I still like icon 2. But then I am rather partial to Orcs...
       
    7. Rocketman919

      Rocketman919 Well-Known Member

      Aug 8, 2008
      2,302
      25
      38
      Cali-forn-i-a
      #27 Rocketman919, Apr 17, 2009
      Nice. The improved icon is much more eye catching, I cant wait to have that on my homescreen :)
       
    8. lazypeon

      lazypeon Well-Known Member
      Patreon Bronze

      Feb 19, 2009
      546
      0
      0
      Software
      San Jose, CA
      #28 lazypeon, Apr 17, 2009
      I voted for Icon1, but the new one looks WAYYY better still. The orc is nice, but I'd describe it as 'muddy' looking. Definitely go with the new version of icon1.
       
    9. romulus

      romulus Well-Known Member

      Mar 30, 2009
      169
      0
      0
      #29 romulus, Apr 17, 2009
      Well done, the finished icon is fantastic!
       
    10. Swordplay

      Swordplay Well-Known Member

      Apr 15, 2009
      280
      0
      0
      Chicago
      #30 Swordplay, Apr 17, 2009
      Good choice! Icons are so important to me. I haven't gotten Topple 2 because of the ugly icon.
       
    11. Gimka

      Gimka Well-Known Member

      Dec 27, 2008
      340
      0
      0
      #31 Gimka, Apr 17, 2009
      Mr. Charley, snow_mani, Rocketman919, lazypeon, romulus, Swordplay,
      Thanks for your approval.

      Our artists spent a full day just to redo the icon carefully based on the feedbacks here. I have to say I’m very impressed myself. The result exceeds my expectation. It’s one of the best looking icons on my homescreen now. It blends really well with the black background. They deserve all the credits; not me.

      snow_mani, don’t worry, you will see lot of Orcs in the game ;)
       
    12. rpb1975

      rpb1975 Well-Known Member

      Feb 5, 2009
      567
      1
      0
      IT Consultant
      Texas
      #32 rpb1975, Apr 17, 2009
      Very well done! I really think this is leaps and bounds ahead of the others! :D
       
    13. Gimka

      Gimka Well-Known Member

      Dec 27, 2008
      340
      0
      0
      #33 Gimka, Apr 17, 2009
      Thanks rpb1975.
      I’m glad we are able to sway you to like the first icon :)
       
    14. arta

      arta Well-Known Member

      Feb 14, 2009
      6,902
      1
      36
      #34 arta, Apr 17, 2009
      Any video?
       
    15. pante

      pante Well-Known Member

      Jan 1, 2009
      1,823
      1
      0
      somewhere
      #35 pante, Apr 17, 2009
      i still think it's nothing special. and don't want to add politics into discussions but it reminds me (to much i think):

      [​IMG]
       
    16. Gimka

      Gimka Well-Known Member

      Dec 27, 2008
      340
      0
      0
      #36 Gimka, Apr 17, 2009
      arta, we have made a video but the resolution is not that good. It won’t do the game justice. We will try to create a better one next week.

      pante, I understand you. But, wow, what can I say? The game is in fantasy setting; so world war politic is not even relevant.
       
    17. Stykman

      Stykman Well-Known Member

      Feb 6, 2009
      2,571
      27
      0
      Beta Tester, Student
      United States
      #37 Stykman, Apr 17, 2009
      wtf is this the soviet union or something??
       
    18. Stykman

      Stykman Well-Known Member

      Feb 6, 2009
      2,571
      27
      0
      Beta Tester, Student
      United States
      #38 Stykman, Apr 17, 2009
      gimka do you guys have a set release date yet for defender chronicles?
       
    19. pante

      pante Well-Known Member

      Jan 1, 2009
      1,823
      1
      0
      somewhere
      #39 pante, Apr 17, 2009
      i'm not talking about the game, but about the icon. :)
       
    20. pante

      pante Well-Known Member

      Jan 1, 2009
      1,823
      1
      0
      somewhere
      #40 pante, Apr 17, 2009
      Soyuz Sovetskikh Sotsialisticheskikh Respublik.
      yes. this icon reminds me a symbol of USSR, but it's just my idea fix.
       
    Page 2 of 3

    Share This Page